Serpent & Dove by Shelby Mahurin Book Review

Updated: Jan 24

Serpent & Dove

by Shelby Mahurin

Published by HarperTeen

Book 1 in the Serpent & Dove Series

Bound as one to love, honor, or burn.

Two years ago, Louise le Blanc fled her coven and took shelter in the city of Cesarine, forsaking all magic and living off whatever she could steal. There, witches like Lou are hunted. They are feared. And they are burned.

Sworn to the Church as a Chasseur, Reid Diggory has lived his life by one principle: thou shalt not suffer a witch to live. His path was never meant to cross with Lou's, but a wicked stunt forces them into an impossible union—holy matrimony.

The war between witches and Church is an ancient one, and Lou's most dangerous enemies bring a fate worse than fire. Unable to ignore her growing feelings, yet powerless to change what she is, a choice must be made.

And love makes fools of us all.


Violence Upper Young Adult Exciting

Steamy Scenes Supernatural


Serpent & Dove by Shelby Mahurin is the first book in her Serpent & Dove series, and follows two characters: Lou (Louise), a witch hiding from her coven in the city of Cesarine, where witchcraft is outlawed, and if caught, witches are burned, and Reid, sworn to the church, a witch hunter. When Lou and Reid are brought together by a misleading looking accident, both of their worlds change forever.

If you are wondering why I am posting this in the weeks I am dedicating to Christmas Stories, well, this book just happens to be around that time of year.

No joke, when I first read the synopsis of Serpent & Dove, I wasn't interested. Despite it being constantly recommended in fantasy book groups, and a suggested read on goodreads and kindle, I was still hesitating. But then two things happened: I started listening to Two Book Bitches, and damn it, they go and do a podcast on this book, and because I loath spoilers, and I love their podcast and wanted to listen to it, I was leaning towards it. Second, I was watching a favorite author of mine, Sarah J Maas, do a instagram live event with the author of this series, and SJM was literally gushing over Reid and Lou ... well I just HAD to read it.

I. Have. No. Regrets.

I loved this book! I loved that the setting is in a fictional world, yet is heavily inspired by the real world. There is Christianity. Women are seen as possessions. Women are burned at the stake (although, unlike our terrible history, witches DO exist in Shelby's world). I really appreciated the way magic is dealt with in this book. It's not the first time I have come across the whole idea that in order to perform a spell, there needs to be a sacrifice in order to maintain a balance, but this is the first time I have come across magic use that is a true sacrifice for the witch. Broken bones, loss of senses, loss of cherished memories ... it fascinated me. And blood magic equally interested me.

If I didn't know beforehand that Shelby was inspired by Outlander (specifically when Jamie and Claire are in Paris, and Jamie called Clare a la dame blanche (white witch), I would have known it after reading the book. Trust me, Serpent & Dove is unique and the plot is NOTHING like Outlander. But we have white witches (Madame Blanches), which is what Lou is, and twice, Reid says one of my favorite Jamie lines from Outlander (and is a pretty major spoiler for this book, so highlight if you want to see) TWICE ------------> "I thank ye to take your hands off my wife." <--------------. Reid's appearance is actually inspired by Sam Heughan, that very talented Scottish actor who portrays Jamie Frasier. So a tiny amount of points are taken away for me, JUST because that line is used. Otherwise ... hey, Outlander is an amazing series. I don't blame anyone from being inspired by it.

If the world, and plot didn't have enough draw, one of the best features of this book are the characters. I'm kinda in love with Lou. She gives no shits about being proper. She is crass, she swears ... she isn't ashamed that she isn't a virgin. She does bad things, but it is for survival, and not because she wants to be evil. She steals. She fights. Which is why when she is paired with Reid, who is ... well ... uptight about rules and propriety, it leads to some hilarious banter. Their genuine dislike for one another, turning to delicious sexual tension and of course, romance, is written so well. They *might* be in my top ten favorite couples that I have read this year.

If you are looking for a book that will make you laugh out loud, weep (which I did ... several times), and will keep you hooked from page one (this book has one of the best opening lines to a book I have every read. Serious chills) to the final page, and have you rooting for a believable enemies to lovers romance, you will not regret picking up Serpent & Dove. Now, off to finally listen to that podcast, and start the next book in the series, Blood & Honey (my review for Blood & Honey will come out after the New Year)

Favorite Moments

  1. Reid and Lou meeting for the first time

  2. Lou saluting at Reid when she is escaping from the robbery

  3. Lou using magic to make the archbishop break wind when he was telling women to obey their husbands

  4. The wedding

  5. Lou stealing Reid's journal

  6. Lou singing Big Titty Liddy to get her way with Ansel

  7. Lou saving Bas

  8. Reid teaching Lou scripture haha

  9. Reid lending Lou a romance book from his secret cubby ... and later admitting it does have a "love" scene

  10. Reid taking Lou to the show, and Reid rubbing circles on the back of her hand.

  11. Lou taking Estelle's pain away from the flames

  12. Lou talking Reid into going Christmas shopping, and when he is cold, she covers him with her cloak.

  13. Reid telling Celie that he is going to honor his marriage vows

  14. Dancing :)

  15. Reid telling Lou he won't touch her until she asks him ... and her trying to kick him out of bed for it lol

  16. Reid calling Lou's buff about stripping naked in public

  17. Lou showing Reid her secret home, and him giving her his mother's ring, a wedding ring.

  18. They have sex!

  19. Lou saving Reid and Ansel

  20. Reid deciding that despite the lies, he loved Lou, and would go after her

  21. Coco telling Reid how her and Lou met

  22. Reid saving Lou's life

Where to Buy

Favorite Quotes

Lou: "Good morning, Babette. You know, it's uncanny the way you always appear within seconds of our money. Can you smell it?"

I turned to Coco, whose lips twitched in an effort not to grin.

Lou: "It's like she can smell it."

Lou: "You're hanging out with the wrong ladies, Chass."

Reid: "Are you a courtesan, then?"

I sighed dramatically

Lou: "Alas, no, and hearts all over Cesarine are breaking for it."

Reid: "Stop laughing."

Lou: "I couldn't even if I wanted to."

She clutched a hand to her side, shaking, and a snort escaped her lips.

Lou: "This right here - this exact moment - it just might be worth marrying you, Chass. I'm going to cherish it forever."

Reid: "You're to be my wife."

Catching up to her in two strides, I reached out to grab her arm, but stopped short of touching her.

Reid: "That means you'll obey me."

Lou: "Does it?"

She raised her brows, still grinning

Lou: "I suppose that means you'll honor and protect me, then? If we're adhering to the dusty old roles of your patriarchy?"

I shortened my pace to match hers.

Reid: "Yes."

She clapped her hands together

Lou: "Excellent. At least this will be entertaining. I have many enemies."

I couldn't help it. I glanced at the deep bruises coloring her eyes.

Reid: "Imagine that."

Lou: "I wouldn't, if I were you. You'll have nightmares for weeks."

Reid: "I told you to behave."

Lou: "Oh, please. I winked. It's not like I stripped and sang 'Big Tittle Liddy' -"

Lou: " 'February twelfth - God took special care in forming Celie.' "

His eyes grew impossibly wider, and he lunged for the journal. I dodged - cackling - and ran into the washroom, locking the door behind me. His fists pounded against the wood.

Reid: "Give me that!"

I grinned and continued reading.

Lou: " 'I long to look upon her face again. Surely there is nothing more beautiful in all the world than her smile - except, of course, her eyes. Or her laugh. Or her lips.' My, my, Chass. Surely thinking of a woman's mouth is impious? What would our dear Archbishop say?"

Reid: "Open - this - door. Right now!"

Lou: " 'But I fear I'm being selfish. Celie has made it clear that my purpose is with my brotherhood.' "


Lou: " 'Though I admire her selflessness, I cannot being myself to agree with her. Any solution that separates us is not a solution at all.' "


Lou: "You're warning me? What are you going to do? Break down the door? Actually, do it. I dare you. 'I must confess, she still haunts my thoughts. Days and nights blur together as one, and I struggle to focus on anything but her memory. My training suffers. I cannot eat. I cannot sleep. There is only her.' Good God, Chass, this is getting depressing. Romantic, of course, but still a little melodramatic for my taste -"

To Ansel's annoyance, I begun to hum.

Ansel: "No humming either."

I ignored him

Lou: "Big Titty Liddy was not very pretty, but her bosom was big as a barn. Her creamery knockers drove men off their rockers, but she was blind to their charms -"

Ansel: "Stop!"

His face burned so vivid a scarlet it rivaled my husband's.

Ansel: "What are you doing? That - that's indecent!"

Lou: "Of course it is. It's a pub song!"

Ansel: "You've been in a pub? But you're a woman."

Lou: "There are lots of women in pubs, Ansel. We aren't like you think. We can do anything you can do - and probably better. There's a whole world outside this church, you know. I could show you, if you wanted."

Ansel: "No. No more talking. No more humming. No more singing. Just - just stop being you for a little while, eh?"

Lou: "I can't make any promises. But if you gave me a tour ..."

Ansel: "Not happening."


Lou: "Big Willy Billy talked sort of silly, but his knob was as long as his -"

Ansel: "Stop, STOP."

Ansel waved his hands, cheeks flaming anew.

Ansel: "I'll take you on a tour - just, please, please stop singing about ... that!"

I rose to my feet, clasping my hands together and beaming.


Lou: "And - and what was that torture device Father Orville was carrying?"

She grinned

Coco: "You mean the Bible?"

Lou: "Very funny."

Lou: "You really think I could knock two fully grown men unconscious?"

Reid: "Yes."

It would be an act of God if I made it through the service without snoring.

After the library fiasco, I'd though it, ah, prudent to accept my husband's invitation to evening Mass. Though I didn't know if he believed Ansel's and my story about learning scripture, he'd latched on to the idea, and I'd spent the remainder of the day memorizing verses. The most diabolical of all punishments.

Reid: " ' A continual dropping in a very rainy day and a contentious woman are alike.' "

he'd recited, eyeing me irritably and waiting for me to repeat the verse. Still peeved from our earlier argument.

Lou: "Rain and men are both pains in the ass."

He scowled but continued.

Reid: " ' Whosoever hideth her hideth the win, and the ointment of his right hand, which bewrayeth itself.' "

Lou: "Whoever hideth her ... something about ointment and a hand ..."

I'd waggled my eyebrows devilishly

Lou: "Quel risque! What sort of book is -"

He'd interrupted before I could further impugn his honor, voice hardening.

Reid: " 'Iron sharpeneth iron; so a man sharpeneth the countenance of his friend.' "

Lou: "Iron sharpeneth iron, so you're being an ass because I, too, am a piece of metal."

On and on and on it'd gone.

Honestly, the invitation to Mass had been a welcome reprieve.

Though my back ached, the exercise kept my irritation in check. I'd quickly learned counting didn't work with Lou ... namely, after she'd started counting right along with me.

Lou: "La Vie Emphemere ..."

She looked up from the cover, lips pursed.

Lou: "The Fleeting Life. What's it about?"

Reid: "It's ... a love story."

Her brows shot up, and she examined the cover with newfound interest.

Lou: "Oh?"

Reid: "Oh."

I nodded, biting the inside of my cheek to keep from smiling.

Reid: "It's tastefully done. The characters are from warring kingdoms, but they're forced to work together when they uncover a plot to destroy the world. They loathe each other initially, but in time, they're able to set aside their differences and -"

Lou: "It's a bodice-ripper, isn't it?"

Reid: "Who is it?"

Ansel: "It's Ansel."

With a grumbled curse, she hopped down. I beat her to the door and pulled it open.

Reid: "What is it?"

Lou glared at him

Lou: "I like you, Ansel, but this had better be something good. Emilie and Alexandre just had a moment, and I swear if they don't kiss soon, I will literally die."

At Ansel's confusion, I shook my head, fighting back a grin.

Reid: "Ignore her."

He was such a brute. A somewhat adorable, pompous-assed brute.

Lou: "Not all witches are evil."

Ansel: "I know you believe that, but you can't force Reid to believe it. There is some things that can't be changed with words. Some things have to be seen. They have to be felt. I hope you can find your way forward together. He's a good person, and ... so are you."

Reid: "Do you promise to behave yourself?"

Lou: "Of course not. That would ruin the fun."

Lou: 'I don't know what the hell you're talking about, but you need to look in the mirror. There's a special circle in Hell for liars and hypocrites, Your Eminence. Perhaps I'll see you there."

Lou: "I want to thank you - for everything. Celie was right. I don't deserve you. I made a real mess or your life when I came into it."

His other hand came down on top of mine. Warm and steady. To my surprise, he smiled.

Reid: "I'm glad you did."

Reid: "You drink like a man."

Lou: "Maybe men can learn a thing or two from women."

Lou: "Oh, c'mon, Chass. I don't bite ... much."

Lou: "Florin? What a terrible name! No wonder he never uses it."

He frowned at me

Reid: "Florin is my middle name."

Lou: "A true tragedy."

Lou: "You don't know me at all."

Reid: "I know stripping in public is too much, even for you. I know you'll never admit you wouldn't have done it."

The amusement in his eyes slowly darkened as he held me, and I became painfully aware this was the closest we'd been since our kiss that morning. He stared at his thumb as it brushed my bottom lip.

Reid: "I know you have a filthy mouth."

He pressed down hard on my lip for emphasis. I shivered.

Reid: "And you're used to getting your way. I know you're vulgar and dishonest and manipulative -"

I recoiled, nose wrinkling, but he only gripped my tighter.

Reid: " - but you're also compassionate and free-spirited and brave. I've n